The Annual JJ Guthrie Award is for the Best and Fairest first grade player each season. Two independent observers & the Coach each rate the best and fairest three players during every first grade game, with three points given to the most deserving player, two to the second, and one point for the remaining player.
The votes are placed in sealed envelopes and kept in the club safe until the JJ Guthrie Award night after the end of competition. During the night the envelopes are opened and the votes publicly counted. The player who gains the most votes overall wins the JJ Guthrie Award for the year. To qualify, players must be financial members and not have been sent off during the season.
The Award honours the memory of former club member John J. Guthrie who died of cancer in 1989.
2009
Cameron Stonely
2008
Brent Murphy
2007
Curtis MacLean
2006
Eugene Maxwell
2005
Dylan Davies
2004
Nathan McCort & Eugene Maxwell
2003
Mark Hill
2002
Kyle Sproul
2001
Darren Murphy
2000
Darren Murphy
1999
Conrad Kovacs
1998
Conrad Kovacs
1997
Conrad Kovacs
1996
Graham Mourie
1995
Ken Angus
1994
Ken Angus
1993
Steve Southworth
1992
Steve Southworth
1991
Conrad Kovacs
1990
Dean McKillop